writing life

Moving On

I had kind of a rough Monday in which a lot of things that had been simmering below the surface came up all at once, which forced me to look at some things in a different way, with the result being that I actually let myself acknowledge some issues, and that may end up leading to some big changes.

So, there’s a good chance that I’m going to quit writing for publication this year. I’m essentially moving backwards, selling fewer and fewer books, making less money, being less known. When I got upset about not being invited to cons, not being considered as a special guest, not being included as a workshop speaker, I tried telling myself that it didn’t really matter, that it was just my ego being bruised. But the fact is, if you’re not known in this business, you’re not selling books. You have to have a certain amount of visibility to get fame, and you have to have a certain amount of fame to get visibility. I’ve had a few times when I seemed close to cracking into that cycle, but it never stuck, and now, after 14 years of being published in fantasy and 14 books, I’m farther away than I ever have been. I’ve done what I can to promote, and now am at the point where making it anywhere is going to take something bigger than me, beyond what I can do, something I can’t control or make happen — a movie or TV series based on one of my books, a celebrity discovering my books and talking about them, going viral in a good way.

Otherwise, maybe this isn’t where I need to be. My work may be lacking whatever “it” it takes to break out. People like it, but it doesn’t seem to generate the kind of passion that makes something take off, that makes a publisher give it a push, that creates an active fandom that gets noticed. There’s also the fact that I really hate being my own publisher. I don’t like having to deal with and negotiate with people to do editing, art, and design. I’m currently in the middle of a weeks-long panic attack about contacting an artist about cover art. I was doing this through my agent, and she handled that stuff, but she got out of that and now it’s on me, and I’m not very good at it and don’t enjoy it, but publishers haven’t been all that interested in me lately, and I don’t have the numbers to get them interested. I like writing, but publishing is getting to me. Meanwhile, I’m making less and less money with each book, and it’s no longer enough to make a living. That means I need to change careers.

I can’t quit right away, since I still have editorial revisions to come on the book for Audible, and I have some other commitments, so I can’t even start looking for a job until May. I’m going to keep working on the book I’m currently writing, and maybe it will be something publishers are interested in and that will make me change my mind. There are things that can happen between now and then that may change the way I feel — if my sales go up, if Enchanted Inc. 9 does really well and gets a lot of attention, if something happens to give me hope that things will get better. I’m just giving myself permission to quit and move on if I still feel the way I do now.

The ninth Enchanted Inc. book will still come out (if I can make myself arrange for cover art). I don’t know beyond that. I may still end up writing in my spare time because that’s what I like doing, but if I go back to a full-time job, I’m not going to force myself to spend my spare time that way, and I may not worry about dealing with publication. I’m so used to working at home that an office job will be a huge adjustment. If it takes a while to find a job, I may work on Rebels 4 in the meantime. Or something wonderful may happen that gets me going again and this will have just been a down phase in my career that makes me appreciate the good things. But at the moment, I think it’s been fun, but I’m ready to move on instead of constantly worrying and struggling and feeling bad.

I’m sorry if I’m leaving any series incomplete or disappointing readers, but I can’t afford to essentially work for below minimum wage and keep taking pay cuts, and I’m just not emotionally up to everything that comes with publishing. I need some financial security and to not have what I’m doing so tied into my self-image.

8 Responses to “Moving On”

  1. Deborah Blake

    I feel you. This is a really tough time for authors, especially those of us who were considered midlevel (not top sellers, not new discoveries, just steady producers of good writing). That section of the publishing world is getting smaller and smaller all the time, and many of those folks are being forced to move into self-publishing, which I, like you, don’t particularly enjoy. Which in turn creates bigger competition for each book dollar, and makes it harder for any given author to get noticed.

    And, of course, once you are dropped by your publisher because you didn’t make them whatever they considered to be “enough” money, your sales drop off, so future publishers think you’re a bad risk. It’s tough out there. (Yes, I am in your position too, in case you can’t tell. My only saving grace for now is that I still have my nonfiction books, which are doing well.)
    Your books are wonderful. The lack of sales or success is no reflection on your talent, just on the state of publishing today. I hope you keep writing, but I sure as hell wouldn’t blame you if you didn’t. Hugs.

    • Shanna Swendson

      It would be nice if Amazon would realize that their system being set up to reward Extruded Book Product over real books was only shooting themselves in the foot, but I’m afraid they’re making too much money from advertising for them to care about making money from keeping customers happy. They’re having the same problem with other products, with their algorithms and policies pushing cheap knock-off products over real things, and customers are starting to feel ripped off. And meanwhile publishers are so all-or-nothing with each trend that comes along.

  2. Tineke

    I’m sorry to hear this, but I understand you should do what best for you. I hope you’ll find work you love if you have to start looking for another job in May. And I know this isn’t about me, but I would love it if you would find time in the coming years to finish the Rebel-series.

  3. Linda Fletcher

    Shanna, thanks for voicing something so many people can identify with these days, but don’t want to talk about. As a writer and current older job-seeker who’s battled discouragement and rejection on a daily basis after being laid off three months ago, my heart goes out to you. I’ve finally learned not to let those negative feelings control me, but I know I still have to look for a job (darn it) because we all gotta do what we gotta do. This Katie and Owen fangirl hopes you’ll keep writing, at least on a part-time basis, so we don’t lose your wonderful voice. But whatever you do, whatever you decide, you’ll knock it out of the park, I just know it. Good luck as you make your decisions!

  4. Sherry Everett

    I hate to hear that you are struggling right now in your career because you are SO incredibly talented! I loved Rebel Mechanics from the first chapter. Everyone I have ever given it to has flown through the series and begged for more. I really hope it works out that you are able to continue writing! I will do what I can to promote your books some more in my library circles!

  5. Debra

    Part of me wants to scream NOOO! But it takes courage to admit when something isn’t working and to take action to move forward. I wish you the best and will keep you in my prayers

  6. Bethany Rawley

    (Copied from Goodreads)
    I’m sorry to hear that you’re thinking of moving on. However, I realize that this process has been a struggle for you. I was inspired to meet you at the North Texas Teen Book Festival last year (I’m going again this year), and I love your books (I’m hoping for a Rebels 4 please- I’m so invested)!! I will miss your wit and creativity, but after working as a copy editor for 4.5 years I understand the need to move on (I’m now a rock star youth librarian). I really hope that you never lose your creative or unique spark! Thank you so much for the joy and excitement that your stories have given me!

  7. Laura

    I feel so bad for you your sales are declining. I will keep hoping for a miracle that will get you back in the spotlights… Hopefully you’ll find an amazing job that will give you a lot of satisfaction.
    I’m looking forward to book 9 of Enchanted Inc., as well as any other book you may still end up writing.

Comments are closed.