Books
Art Based on Life
by
I got to my latest read through an odd rabbit trail that spanned a few years. I’m not sure where I first heard about the Mitford sisters. I think they came up through something else I was reading when I was in a “between the wars” phase a few years ago and reading about life in the 20s and 30s. They were sort of the Kardashians of England in that era, daughters of a minor nobleman who ran with the “bright young things” crowd of London in the 30s. Their father thought educating girls was a waste, so they weren’t sent to school. They had a few years with governesses and went to finishing school but otherwise were mostly self educated by reading the books in their home library. And yet most of them ended up writing books and two of them were professional authors and journalists. The family was also pretty notorious for their politics. One sister left her husband to become the mistress (and later wife, after his wife died) of the founder of the British Union of Fascists. Another was such a Hitler fangirl that she got her father to send her to Munich to practice German, then basically stalked Hitler until she intrigued him enough that he asked to be introduced to her and she became part of his social circle, eventually introducing most of the rest of the family to him. Then there was the sister who became a communist and ran away to be part of the civil war in Spain.
The oldest sister, Nancy, became a novelist, writing satirical novels that were quite transparently based on her own family. I’d seen TV productions of The Pursuit of Love and Love in a Cold Climate before I knew anything about the author, and they were close enough to reality that when I was reading a book on the family I got a strange sense of deja vu and wondered why these events seemed so familiar. Now I’ve finally read the novels themselves.
The books have an interesting structure for a series in that they actually take place around the same time rather than the second book being a true sequel. Our narrator isn’t the main character of either book. She’s mostly an observer of her wacky relatives, so the second book covers another part of her family during the events of the first book where she’s not present and is relating things that she later heard about. The first book covers her mother’s relatives, a large family she spends holidays with. The cousin she’s closest to wants desperately to be in love and makes some pretty big leaps along the way as she tries to find it, including an early, ill-fated marriage and running away with an idealistic young communist. The second book is about some relatives on the narrator’s father’s side, a family with a beautiful daughter who’s sure to be a hit on the society marriage market because of her great beauty, but she’s cool and aloof and doesn’t seem to have any interest in any of the men she meets. But there’s a reason: She’s been in love since childhood with someone unavailable and unsuitable, and when he becomes available it throws the family into turmoil.
Oddly, these books reminded me a lot of Jane Austen. It seems like the sort of thing Austen might have written if she’d been writing about the 1920s and 1930s. They cover the same sort of country gentry/minor aristocracy set and the same “it’s critical to find a husband” issues and have the same sometimes over-the-top satirical characterizations. I wonder if it’s coincidence or deliberate the our narrator sent off to stay with relatives is named Fanny, like the heroine of Mansfield Park. Both characters are kind of meek and mousy and dealing with their scandalous family, though with different outcomes, and the Fanny in these books isn’t penniless. The voice is very Austen-like. Of course, there’s subject matter that Austen wouldn’t have touched, but she was writing in the late 1700s and early 1800s. She might have been racier in the 1930s.
I feel like I also detected some influences for Downton Abbey. Nancy Mitford herself seems like a model for some of Edith’s storylines, as the daughter of a nobleman who ends up writing for a magazine. Then there’s a storyline of a family who has only a daughter, so the estate will be inherited by a distant relative they’ve never met, so they invite him to come stay at the manor with them (though this character is nothing like Matthew in Downton Abbey, and no one dies on the Titanic for him to become the heir).
There’s not a lot of story structure to these books, and I’d say my biggest complaint is that they sort of fizzle out at the end. The characters come to an end of that phase in their life and the books just stop. They seem to be going for a “slice of life” thing rather than having any kind of arc. It leaves a somewhat dissatisfying feeling, like the story’s incomplete. It’s worse with Love in a Cold Climate because that one ends on a big change, but we don’t get to see the change. There is a third book, but it takes place more than a decade later and focuses on the narrator character. My library system has it, so I’ll have to read it and see if it also lets us know what became of the other people.
If you like Jane Austen for her snarky voice and skewering of certain character types and wonder how she’d have written about the 20th century, these might be worth looking into. But learning anything about the Mitfords can set off some research rabbit trails, and there are a lot of related works. For instance, there’s a series of mysteries with Nancy Mitford as one of the amateur sleuths (written by someone connected to Downton Abbey, which confirms my suspicion that the writer was at least aware of Nancy Mitford), and there’s a historical novel about Nancy Mitford’s relationship with her fascist sister, based on the premise that Nancy figured out she might be feeding info to the Germans and was the one who turned her in so that she spent much of the war in custody.
