movies
Down the Rabbit Hole
Last weekend’s movie viewing was the two Tim Burton Alice in Wonderland movies. I’d seen the first one, sort of. It was at a social event where the movie provided the theme but mostly served as background noise while we ate dinner and did crafts. I didn’t remember much about it, and I went home before they started the second one.
I was never a huge Alice in Wonderland fan. I had the book as a kid and read it, but it didn’t click with me in a big way. I also had the Disney “story and songs” record, which was not actually a recording of the movie soundtrack. It seems to have been studio versions by different performers, and it included full versions of songs that only had a line or two in the movie, like the jazzy version of the Jabberwocky poem. When I finally saw the movie, I was disappointed because the music wasn’t nearly as good and the movie was kind of boring. Still, this was pretty much the prototype for the portal fantasy type of story in which a young person (usually a girl) travels to a magical or fantastic land and has adventures before going back home. Narnia owes some debt to Wonderland.
In spite of not being a huge Alice fan girl, I have visited the Alice shop in Oxford, which is apparently in a shop that was mentioned in the book, and I’ve been to the Alice’s Tea Room restaurant in New York (I was there more for the tea than because of the theme).
I still think that my favorite Alice-related telling is Once Upon a Time in Wonderland, but I did enjoy the take on the story in these movies. It was an interesting idea to have an adult Alice going through more or less the events of the book (with some twists and changes) but it being the second time, with her thinking the time she went as a child (and lived out the events of the book) was just a dream. That allowed the story to be a bit more adult while still somewhat following the book and also including new stuff. I liked the theme of Alice having to find her childhood “muchness” again and then bringing that with her back to her regular life.
I may have liked the second movie even better. They’re not even trying to follow the books in this one. It’s an entirely new story involving time travel as Alice returns to Underland (it seems she got the name of the place wrong) to help save the Hatter, and she ends up going back in time to see if she can make things better for him by fixing the past. At the same time, she wants to fix something that went wrong for the Red and White Queens. I was a little worried that they’d go with the “it’s really the good guy’s fault that the bad guy is evil” story there, and they came close, but I don’t think they were really saying that it was all the White Queen’s fault because of something she did as a child, just that she did owe her sister an apology.
The weak link for me was Johnny Depp’s Mad Hatter. He was just so aggressively weird and creepy, with the same sort of persona he put on for playing Willy Wonka. In this story, he’s supposed to be so endearing that everyone is willing to do anything to help him, and that doesn’t work when you’re having a visceral “Ew!” reaction to this character, who’s played like late-stage Michael Jackson hosting a children’s television program but without understanding children. Otherwise, it’s a pretty impressive cast.
I like this take on Wonderland/Underland, with a bit of a steampunk aesthetic and the costuming is lovely.
And, unlike so many other movies these days, these are both pretty short movies, under 2 hours. Even the Disney live action remakes of the cartoons tend to go over two hours, so I have to start a movie early in the evening to be done by bedtime.


